Questions Submitted for Discussion at the First Meeting; Minutes of the First Meeting, November 22, 1934.


Questions for first meeting of Continuing Committee

Minutes of first meeting of Continuing Committee

In June 1934, President Franklin Roosevelt appointed a special Committee on Economic Security (CES), whose purpose was to make recommendations on proposals which would promote greater economic security. The Committee was composed of five cabinet members, under the leadership of Secretary of Labor Frances Perkins, as well as a number of nationally-recognized experts in field of social work who served as advisors to the committee. Msgr. John O'Grady, the head of the NCCC, was among the influential advisors who aided the CES in drafting the Social Security bill.

In November, the National Conference of Catholic Charities formed a new internal committee whose purpose was to lobby for acceptable language in the new bill: this is the beginning of the NCCC's active organizational involvement in shaping of the Social Security Act of 1935. The first document presented here, written by O'Grady, summarizes the aims of the President's Committee on Economic Security and poses questions for discussion at the first meeting of the new NCCC committee. It represents O'Grady's attempt to get input from the diocesan-level directors of Catholic charities so that any recommendations he made to the CES would reflect a Catholic perspective on social welfare. The second document is the minutes of that first meeting, recording the discussion that ensued and the diocesan directors' perspective on the need for federal social legislation.



As you read the documents, reflect on the following questions:

  • Who are the members of the President's Committee on Economic Security? What are the committee's purposes and objectives?
  • According to the first document, the CES recognized that any "comprehensive, long-term security program" must cover include four major components. What are they?
  • As reported in the minutes of the November 22 meeting, one of the problems faced by the diocesan directors was that of keeping up-to-date on changes to federal policies and plans relating to social welfare. What solution was proposed by the committee as a way of keeping all the members informed of developments in the social security movement?
  • The committee discussed its own purpose and function as well as that of the President's CES. What did the committee members hope would be the outcome of their "quiet and constructive" work?
  • Why do you think the committee spend so much time discussing the lack of Catholic representation on the CES?